Classification of Expenses
Below are descriptions of the various classifications of expenses used by Central Michigan University on its financial reporting. This information was adapted from the Financial Accounting and Reporting Manual for Higher Education published by the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO).
When presenting expenses by functional expense categories in their general-purpose financial statements, public institutions should use the following functional expense classifications:
- Instruction
- Research
- Public Service
- Academic Support
- Student Services
- Institutional Support
- Operation and Maintenance of Plant
- Scholarships and Fellowships
- Depreciation
- Auxiliary Enterprises
- Other Self Supporting Enterprises
Instruction
The instruction category includes expenses for all activities that are part of an institution's instruction program. Expenses for credit and noncredit courses; academic, vocational, and technical instruction; remedial and tutorial instruction; and regular, special, and extension sessions should be included.
Expenses for departmental research and public service that are not separately budgeted should be included in this classification. This category excludes expenses for those academic personnel whose primary activity is administration; for example, academic deans.
The instruction category includes the following subcategories:
- General Academic Instruction. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted instructional activities that are carried out during the academic year (as defined by the institution), associated with academic offerings described by the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) instructional program categories identified in the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) publication, A Classification of Instructional Programs, and offered for credit as part of a formal post-secondary education degree or certificate program. Open university, short courses, and home study activities falling within this classification and offered for credit are included. However, this subcategory does not include instructional offerings that are part of programs leading toward degrees or certificates at levels below the higher educational level, such as adult basic education.
- Vocational/Technical Instruction. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted instructional activities that are carried out during the academic year (as defined by the institution), usually associated with IPEDS instructional program categories and offered for credit as part of a formal postsecondary education degree or certificate program. Open university, short courses, and home study falling within this classification and offered for credit are included. However, this subcategory does not include instructional offerings that are part of programs leading toward degrees or certificates at levels below the higher education level, such as adult basic education.
- Community Education. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted instructional activities that do not generally result in credit toward any formal postsecondary degree or certificate. It includes noncredit instructional offerings carried out by the institution's extension division as well as noncredit offerings that are part of the adult education or continuing education program. This subcategory also includes expenses for activities associated with programs leading toward a degree or certificate at a level below the higher education level, such as adult basic education.
- Preparatory/Remedial Instruction. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted instructional activities that give students the basic knowledge and skills required by the institution before they can undertake formal academic coursework leading to a postsecondary degree or certificate. Such activities, supplemental to the normal academic program, generally are termed preparatory, remedial, developmental, or special educational services. These instructional offerings may be taken before or along with the coursework leading to the degree or certificate. They are generally noncredit offerings, although in some cases credit may be provided specifically for required preparatory or remedial skills or knowledge, and should be included in this category. If students may meet satisfactory preparatory requirements by taking offerings provided primarily for other than remedial or preparatory purposes, those, offerings should be classified elsewhere.
- Instructional Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted instructional information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to institutional support.
Research
The research category includes all expenses for activities specifically organized to produce research, whether commissioned by an agency external to the institution or separately budgeted by an organizational unit within the institution. Subject to these conditions, the category includes expenses for individual and/or project research as well as that of institutes and research centers. This category does not include all sponsored programs nor is it necessarily limited to sponsored research, since internally supported research programs, if separately budgeted, might be included in this category under the circumstances described. Expenses for departmental research that are separately budgeted are included in this category. However, the research category does not include expenses for departmental research that are not separately budgeted. Such expenses are included in the instructional category.
The research category includes the following subcategories:
- Institutes and Research Centers. This subcategory includes expenses for research activities that are part of a formal research organization created to manage many research efforts. While this subcategory includes agricultural experiment stations, it does not include federally funded research and development centers, which, for public institutions, should continue to be classified as independent operations.
- Individual and Project Research. This subcategory includes expenses for research activities that are managed within academic departments. Such activities may have been undertaken as the result of a research contract or grant or through a specific allocation of the institution's general resources.
- Research Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted research information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to institutional support.
Public service
The public service category includes expenses for activities established primarily to provide non-instructional services beneficial to individuals and groups external to the institution. These activities include community service programs (excluding instructional activities) and cooperative extension services. Included in this category are conferences, institutes, general advisory services, reference bureaus, radio and television, consulting, and similar non-instructional services to particular sectors of the community.
The public service category includes the following subcategories:
- Community Service. This subcategory includes expenses for activities organized and carried out to provide general community services, excluding instructional activities. Community service activities make available to the public various resources and special capabilities that exist within the institution. Examples include conferences and institutes, general advisory services and reference bureaus, consultation, testing services (for example, soil testing, carbon dating, structural testing), and similar activities. The activities included in this subcategory are generally sponsored and managed outside the context of both the agricultural and urban extension programs and of the institution's public broadcasting station.
- Cooperative Extension Service. This subcategory includes expenses for non-instructional public service activities established as the result of cooperative extension efforts between the institution and outside agencies such as the U.S. Department of Agriculture's extension service and the affiliated state extension services. This subcategory is intended primarily for land-grant colleges and universities and includes both agricultural extension and urban extension services. The distinguishing feature of activities in this subcategory is that programmatic and fiscal control is shared by the institution with the Department of Agriculture's extension service, the related state extension services, and agencies of local government.
- Public Broadcasting Services. This subcategory includes expenses for the operation and maintenance of broadcasting services operated outside the context of the institution's instruction, research, and academic support programs. Excluded from this subcategory are broadcasting services conducted primarily in support of instruction (classified in the subcategory ancillary support), broadcasting services operated primarily as a student service activity (classified in the subcategory social and cultural development), and broadcasting services that are independent operations (classified in the subcategory independent operations/institutional).
- Public Service Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted public service information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to institutional support.
Academic support
The academic support category includes expenses incurred to provide support services for the Institution's primary missions: instruction, research, and public service. It includes the retention, preservation, and display of educational materials, such as libraries, museums, and galleries; the provision of services that directly assist the academic functions of the institution, such as demonstration schools associated with a department, school, or college of education; media such as audio-visual services and technology such as computing support; academic administration (including academic deans but not department chairpersons) and personnel development providing administration support and management direction to the three primary missions; and separately budgeted support for course and curriculum development. For institutions that currently charge some of the expenses-for example, computing support-directly to the various operating units of the institution, this category does not reflect such expenses.
This category includes the following subcategories:
- Libraries. This subcategory includes expenses for organized activities that directly support the operation of a cataloged or otherwise classified collection.
- Museums and Galleries. This subcategory includes expenses for, organized activities that provide for the collection, preservation, and exhibition of historical materials, art objects, scientific displays, etc. Libraries are excluded.
- Educational Media Services. This subcategory includes expenses for organized activities providing audiovisual and other services that aid in the transmission of information in support of the institution's instruction, research, and public service programs.
- Academic Support Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted academic support information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense, information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to this category and the remainder to institutional support.
- Ancillary Support. This subcategory includes expenses for organized activities that provide support services to the three primary programs of instruction, research, and public service, but are not appropriately classified in the previous subcategories. Ancillary support activities usually provide a mechanism through which students can gain practical experience. An example of ancillary support is a demonstration school associated with a school of education. The expenses of teaching hospitals are excluded.
- Academic Administration. This subcategory includes expenses for activities specifically designed and carried out to provide administrative and management support to the academic programs. This subcategory is intended to separately identify expenses for activities formally organized and/or separately budgeted for academic administration. It includes the expenses of academic deans (including deans of research, deans of graduate schools, and college deans), but it does not include the expenses of department chairpersons (which are included in the appropriate primary function categories). The subcategory also includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted academic advising. Expenses associated with the office of the chief academic officer of the institution are not included in this subcategory but should be classified as institutional support.
- Academic Personnel Development. This subcategory includes expenses for activities that provide the faculty with opportunities for personal and professional growth and development to the extent that such activities are formally organized and/or separately budgeted. This subcategory also includes formally organized and/or separately budgeted activities that evaluate and reward the professional performance of the faculty. Included in this subcategory are sabbaticals, faculty awards, and organized faculty development programs.
- Course and Curriculum Development. This subcategory includes expenses for activities established either to significantly improve or to add to the institution's instructional offerings, but only to the extent that such activities are formally organized and/or separately budgeted.
Student services
The student services category includes expenses incurred for offices of admissions and the registrar and activities with the primary purpose of contributing to students' emotional and physical well-being and intellectual, cultural, and social development outside the context of the formal instruction program. It includes expenses for student activities, cultural events, student newspapers, intramural athletics, student organizations, intercollegiate athletics (if the program is not operated as an essentially self-supporting activity), counseling, and career guidance (excluding informal academic counseling by the faculty), student aid administration, and student health service (if not operated as an essentially self-supporting activity). In recent years, some institutions have created an office of enrollment management; expenses for such an office are best categorized in student services.
The student services category includes the following subcategories:
- Student Services Administration. This subcategory includes expenses for organized administrative activities that provide assistance and support (excluding academic support) to the needs and interests of students. This subcategory includes only administrative activities that support more than one subcategory of student activities and/or that provide central administrative services related to the various student service activities. In particular, this subcategory includes services provided for particular types of students (for example, minority students, veterans, and handicapped students). Excluded from this subcategory are the activities of the institution's chief administrative officer for student affairs, whose activities are institution-wide and therefore should be classified as institutional support.
- Social and Cultural Development. This subcategory includes expenses for organized activities that provide for students' social and cultural development outside the formal academic program. This subcategory includes cultural events, student newspapers, intramural athletics, student organizations, etc. Expenses for an intercollegiate athletics program are included in this subcategory if the program is not operated as an essentially self-supporting operation (in which case all the related expenses would be reported as auxiliary enterprises).
- Counseling and Career Guidance. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized placement, career guidance, and personal counseling services for students. This subcategory includes vocational testing and counseling services and activities of the placement office. Excluded from this subcategory are formal academic counseling activities (academic support) and informal academic counseling services (instruction) provided by the faculty concerning course assignments.
- Financial Aid Administration. This subcategory includes expenses for activities that provide financial aid services and assistance to students. This subcategory does not include outright grants to students, which should be classified as either revenue reductions, agency transactions, or expenses, as discussed elsewhere.
- Student Admissions. This subcategory includes expenses for activities related to the identification of prospective students, the promotion of attendance at the institution, and the processing of applications for admission.
- Student Records. This subcategory includes expenses for activities to maintain, handle and update records for currently enrolled students as well as for students previously enrolled.
- Student Health Services. This subcategory includes expenses for organized student health services that are not self-supporting; self-supporting health services are reported as auxiliary enterprises.
- Student Services Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted student services information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to institutional support.
Institutional support
The institutional support category includes expenses for central, executive-level activities concerned with management and long-range planning for the entire institution, such as the governing board, planning and programming operations, and legal services; fiscal operations, including the investment office; administrative data processing; space management; employee personnel and records; logistical activities that provide procurement, storerooms, printing; transportation services to the institution; support services to faculty and staff that are not operated as auxiliary enterprises; and activities concerned with community and alumni relations, including development and fundraising.
Appropriate allocations of institutional support should be made to auxiliary enterprises, hospitals, and any other activities not directly related to the primary program categories or the related support categories.
This category includes the following subcategories:
- Executive Management. This subcategory includes expenses for all central, executive-level activities concerned with management and long-range planning for the entire institution (as distinct from planning and management for any one program within the institution). All officers with institution-wide responsibilities are included, such as the president, chief academic officer, chief business officer, chief student affairs officer, and chief development officer. This subcategory includes such operations as executive direction (for example, governing board), planning and programming operations, and legal operations.
- Fiscal Operations. This subcategory includes expenses for operations related to fiscal control and investments. It includes the accounting office, bursar's office, and external audits. Interest expense on working capital loans is recorded with other interest expenses and is not recorded as institutional support. In addition, bad debt expense for student and other accounts receivables is recorded as a reduction in the specific revenue source rather than as an expense.
- General Administration. This subcategory includes expenses for activities related to general administrative operations and services (with the exception of fiscal operations and administrative information technology). Included in this subcategory are personnel administration, space management, purchasing and maintenance of supplies and materials, campus-wide communications and transportation services, general stores, and printing shops.
- Administrative Information Technology. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted administrative information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to this category.
- Public Relations/Development. This subcategory includes expenses for activities to maintain relations with the community, alumni, or other constituents and to conduct activities related to institution-wide development and fundraising. Public institutions are also required to follow the provisions in Statement of Position 98-2, Accounting for Costs of Activities of Not-for-Profit Organizations and State and Local Governmental Entities That Include Fund Raising. This SOP requires that if certain criteria, namely purpose, audience, and content, are met, the costs of the activity should be allocated between fundraising and the appropriate program or management and general function. If all of the criteria are not met then the entire amount is classified as fundraising costs. In addition, certain disclosures are required.
Operations and maintenance of plant
The operation and maintenance of plant category includes all expenses for the administration, supervision, operation, maintenance, preservation, and protection of the institution's physical plant. They include expenses normally incurred for such items as janitorial and utility services; repairs and ordinary or normal alterations of buildings. furniture, and equipment; care of grounds; maintenance and operation of buildings and other plant facilities; security; earthquake and disaster preparedness; safety; hazardous waste disposal; property, liability, and all other insurance relating to property; space and capital leasing; facility planning and management; and central receiving. It does not include interest expense on capital-related debt.
This category may be allocated to the other functional categories based on an acceptable allocation methodology such as the square footage of buildings.
This category includes the following subcategories:
- Physical Plant Administration. This subcategory includes expenses for administrative activities that directly support physical plant operations. Activities related to the development of plans for plant expansion or modification, as well as plans for new construction, should be included in this subcategory. Also included are property, liability, and all other insurance relating to property.
- Building Maintenance. This subcategory includes expenses for activities related to routine repair and maintenance of buildings and other structures, including normally recurring repairs and preventive maintenance.
- Custodial Services. This subcategory includes expenses related to custodial services in buildings.
- Utilities. This subcategory includes expenses related to heating, cooling, light and power, gas, water, and any other utilities necessary for the operation of the physical plant.
- Landscape and Grounds Maintenance. This subcategory includes expenses related to the operation and maintenance of landscape and grounds.
- Major Repairs and Renovations. This subcategory includes expenses related to major repairs, maintenance, and renovations. Minor repairs should be classified as building maintenance. The institution should define the distinction between major repairs and minor repairs. Costs that will be capitalized in accordance with the institution's capitalization policy are excluded.
- Security and Safety. This subcategory includes expenses related to security; earthquake and disaster preparedness; safety, including environmental safety; and hazardous waste disposal.
- Logistical Services. This subcategory includes expenses related to logistical services such as central receiving as well as space and capital leasing.
- Operations and Maintenance Information Technology. NACUBO's Advisory Report 99-3 added this subcategory. This subcategory includes expenses for formally organized and/or separately budgeted operation and maintenance of information technology. If an institution does not separately budget and expense information technology resources, the costs associated with the three primary programs will be applied to academic support and the remainder to institutional support.
Scholarships and fellowships
Public institutions, after the adoption of GASB Statements 34 and 35, should report tuition discounts and allowances and scholarships generally as reductions of tuition and fees revenues. Certain amounts of such items should still be reported as expenses in general-purpose financial statements. Institutional resources provided to students as financial aid should be recorded as scholarship allowances in amounts up to and equal to amounts owed by students to the institution. Institutional resources provided in excess of amounts owed by the students to the institution and refunded to students should be recorded as expenses. See 312.111 for a detailed discussion of such requirements.
In addition, NACUBO has issued Advisory Report 2000-5 that sets forth and illustrates the appropriate accounting and reporting or various types of tuition discounts and scholarships under GASB Statements 34 and 35. Institutions, in applying this guidance on allocating financial aid between revenue discounts and expenses, will generally initially record all aid as an expense and then determine the amount of aid that should be reported as a reduction of revenues. Accordingly, it is still advisable to maintain expense accounts for aid granted. The scholarships and fellowships category includes expenses for scholarships and fellowships- from restricted or unrestricted funds-in the form of grants to students, resulting from selection by the institution or from an entitlement program. The category also includes trainee stipends, prizes, and awards. Trainee stipends awarded to individuals who are not enrolled in formal coursework should be charged to instruction, research, or public service. Recipients of grants are not required to perform service to the institution as consideration for the grant, nor are they expected to repay the amount of the grant to the funding source. When services are required in exchange for financial assistance, as in the College Work-Study program, charges should be classified as expenses of the department or organizational unit to which the service is rendered. Aid to students in the form of tuition or fee remissions also should be included in this category. However, remission of tuition or fees granted because of faculty or staff status, or family relationship of students to faculty or staff, should be recorded as staff benefits expenses in the appropriate functional expense category.
This category includes the following subcategories:
- Scholarships. This subcategory includes grants-in-aid, trainee stipends, tuition and fee waivers, and prizes to undergraduate students.
- Fellowships. This subcategory includes grants-in-aid and trainee stipends to graduate students. It does not include funds for which services to the institution must be rendered, such as payments for teaching.
Depreciation
Depreciation expense should be calculated in accordance with the institution's capitalization and depreciation policies. See ¶ 308 on capital assets for additional information. Depreciation expense is considered both a functional and natural expense classification under GASS Statements 34 -and 35. In addition, when functional expenses are reported in the Statement of Revenues, Expenses, and Changes in Net Assets, depreciation expense can be allocated to other functions such as instruction, research, and student services, or allocated only to plant operation and maintenance expenses, or reported separately. When depreciation expense is reported as a functional expense, depreciation for all activities (educational and general, auxiliary enterprises and hospitals) may be combined and. reported as one amount in the Statement of Revenues, Expenses, and Changes in Net Assets, or it may be segregated between these activities if the Statement shows separate columns or other means to delineate expenses between these activities.
The allocation methodology may be either a simple or complex one such as a multiple allocation approach. Generally, depreciation expense for buildings may be allocated based on the usage of the buildings. This is accomplished by a periodic inventory of the usage of the space in each building. Depreciation expenses on equipment may be allocated to other functions based on the location of the equipment and the use of that space. This is also accomplished through a periodic inventory of the equipment.
Auxiliary enterprises
An auxiliary enterprise exists to furnish goods or services to students, faculty, staff, other institutional departments, or incidentally to the general public, and charges a fee directly related to, although not necessarily equal to, the cost of the goods or services. The distinguishing characteristic of an auxiliary enterprise is that it is managed as an essentially self-supporting activity. Examples are residence halls, food services, intercollegiate athletics (only if essentially self-supporting), college stores, faculty clubs, parking, and faculty housing. Student health services, when operated as an auxiliary enterprise, also are included. Hospitals, although they may serve students, faculty, or staff, are classified separately because of their financial significance.
The auxiliary enterprise category includes all expenses relating to the operation of auxiliary enterprises, including expenses for the operation and maintenance of the plant, depreciation (if allocated to functional expense categories) and administration. Also included are other direct and indirect costs, whether charged directly as expenses or allocated as a proportionate share of costs of other departments or units. To ensure that data regarding individual auxiliary enterprises are complete and adequate for management decisions, cost data should be prepared using full costing methods. Costing means that the costs attributed to each enterprise include a portion of indirect costs related to that enterprise, as well as the costs directly attributable to its operation.
This category includes the following subcategories:
- Auxiliary Enterprises-Student. This subcategory includes expenses for auxiliary enterprise activities primarily intended to furnish services to students. A student health service, when operated as an auxiliary enterprise, is included. However, intercollegiate athletics are excluded from this category.
- Auxiliary Enterprises-Faculty/Staff. This subcategory includes expenses for auxiliary enterprise activities primarily intended to provide a service to the faculty, staff or both. Such activities include the faculty club, faculty-staff parking, and faculty housing.
- Intercollegiate Athletics. This subcategory includes expenses for an intercollegiate sports program when the program is operated in accordance with the definition of an auxiliary enterprise (essentially self-supporting).
- Auxiliary Enterprises-Other. This subcategory includes expenses for auxiliary enterprise activities primarily intended to furnish goods and services that are related to the higher education mission. Customers for these goods and services generally are not students, faculty, or staff. Entities of this type are formed to meet the geographic and public service needs of a region and generally relate to an institution's mission of teaching, research, or public service. Examples of such art entity would be a drug testing center or a university press department.
Other self-supporting enterprises
This subcategory includes activities that were established primarily to provide goods and services to other internal units on a fee-for-service basis.
The following characteristics assist in identifying these units:
- They are self-supporting units that operate on a break-even basis for those goods and services offered to other units.
- They could provide, to a lesser extent, the same goods and services to faculty, staff, students, and related entities.
- The goods and services are provided at an institutional level. This characteristic excludes enterprises that only serve units within the same department. For example, a telecommunications department that services the entire institution would be considered other self-supporting while the chemistry stores department that only services other chemistry units would be reported net within academic support under functional expense reporting.